Torani vs Jordan's Skinny Syrup: Which to Buy? (November 2026)

On this page (8 sections)

1. Torani vs Jordan's Skinny Syrup: the quick verdict
2. The two brands side by side
3. Which brand wins on flavor for hot drinks?
4. Which brand wins on soda and cold drinks?
5. Sweeteners, calories and what's in the bottle
6. Bottle sizes and how long a pack lasts
7. Who should buy which brand?
8. The verdict: Torani vs Jordan's Skinny Syrup

Pick Jordan's Skinny Syrups for sweetening coffee and dessert drinks; pick Torani for fruit-forward sodas and Italian sodas. Jordan's takes the overall win in this Torani vs Jordan's Skinny Syrup comparison because its flavors land where most people use syrup first: a daily latte or iced coffee.

Torani's soda pack wins only if your drinks are cold, fruity and fizzy.

Both brands sell sugar free syrup, so the choice isn't about calories. It's about what you pour the syrup into.

Jordan's Skinny Mixes builds its range around coffeehouse flavors like vanilla and chocolate, while Torani's variety pack here is built around fruit flavors for sodas, iced teas and lemonades.

Torani vs Jordan's Skinny Syrup: the quick verdict

Jordan's Skinny Syrups is the better buy for most readers. Its vanilla coffee syrup scores highest here, and the brand's simple syrup covers the drinks that need sweetness without flavor.

That pairing handles coffee, tea, protein shakes and cocktails without forcing you into a fruit flavor you didn't want.

Torani still earns a place. The four-bottle soda pack gives you raspberry, coconut, strawberry and peach in one order, which is more variety than any single Jordan's pack in this comparison.

If your fridge is full of sparkling water and your coffee is black, Torani is the smarter first purchase.

The split comes down to temperature and taste. Hot drinks and dessert flavors point to Jordan's, while cold, fruity and bubbly drinks point to Torani.

Neither brand wins everything, which is why the next sections break the choice down by what actually goes in your glass.

The two brands side by side

The table below lines up the four products in this comparison on flavor, pack size and sweetener. Use it to find the row that matches your usual drink before reading the deeper sections.

Jordan's Skinny Mixes makes sugar free coffee syrups and drink mixes, and its coffee syrup line is made in the USA. The vanilla pack holds two 25.4 fl oz bottles, the simple syrup comes as one 25.4 fl oz bottle, and the signature chocolate pack holds two bottles, one salted dark chocolate espresso and one chocolate caramel truffle.

Torani's soda variety pack holds four 25.4 fl oz bottles, one each of raspberry, coconut, strawberry and peach. Torani sweetens its sugar free syrups with sucralose, and the pack lists zero sugar and zero carbs.

The brand traces its history to 1925 in San Francisco, where its founders used handwritten Italian recipes to bring the Italian soda to their neighborhood.

What each brand is built for

Jordan's is a coffee-first brand. Its flavors are the ones you'd order at a cafe: vanilla, caramel, mocha, chocolate.

The packs here lean sweet and dessert-like, and the simple syrup is the blank canvas of the lineup.

Torani is broader. The full range runs past 100 syrups across coffee, soda, tea, cocktails and more.

The pack in this comparison, though, is a soda pack, and every bottle in it is a fruit flavor meant for cold drinks.

That difference in focus is the real story of Torani vs Jordan's skinny syrup. You're not choosing between good and bad.

You're choosing between a coffee flavor shelf and a soda flavor shelf. Torani's soda pack even includes coconut, which reads tropical rather than cafe-style, and peach, which leans toward iced tea.

Jordan's packs stay in the dessert aisle throughout.

Which brand wins on flavor for hot drinks?

Jordan's wins for hot drinks. Its vanilla, chocolate and espresso flavors are made for lattes, mochas and after-dinner coffee.

Torani's four-bottle pack doesn't include a single flavor you'd want in a hot latte.

The Jordan's vanilla coffee syrup is the safest entry point. Vanilla plays well with coffee, tea, overnight oats, yogurt and protein shakes, so one pack covers more of your day than a fruit syrup would.

Stir in about a tablespoon to start and adjust from there. It's dairy free as well as gluten free and kosher, so it fits a dairy-free coffee routine.

The signature pack goes further. Salted dark chocolate espresso and chocolate caramel truffle are dessert flavors, and they suit a mocha or an iced espresso drink better than a plain cup of coffee.

If you already have vanilla covered, this is the pack that adds something new. The two flavors also give you a way to switch between a salty-dark profile and a sweeter truffle one without buying two separate bottles.

Torani's fruit flavors can go into hot tea, but that's not what they're for. Raspberry or peach in a hot latte tastes muddled.

Save the Torani pack for cold drinks and let Jordan's handle everything you brew hot.

How to use the Jordan's chocolate pack well

Salted dark chocolate espresso is the stronger of the two flavors, so start with less than you would with vanilla. A small amount stirred into a mocha or an iced espresso keeps the salt and chocolate from swamping the coffee.

Chocolate caramel truffle is sweeter and rounder. Use it when you want a dessert drink rather than a coffee with a hint of flavor, and add it to steamed milk for a homemade mocha base.

Both bottles are gluten free, keto and kosher, so the pack fits the same diet rules as the vanilla and simple syrups.

Which brand wins on soda and cold drinks?

Torani wins for soda and cold drinks. Its variety pack is four fruit flavors built for Italian sodas, iced teas and lemonades, and that's a better fit for a fizzy drink than a vanilla or chocolate syrup.

Carbonate your water first, then add syrup to the glass.

Starting with a small pour lets you taste the fruit before the sweetness takes over. Raspberry and strawberry are the safest picks for a first soda, while coconut and peach are more distinctive and worth trying in iced tea.

This is also where the brand's soda heritage shows. Torani's founders brought the Italian soda to San Francisco, and the soda pack carries that idea forward with flavors meant to be mixed into cold, bubbly drinks.

The pack covers iced teas and lemonades as well as sodas, so a single bottle can cover more than one cold drink. Our SodaStream MIX vs Terra comparison covers which machine to pair with syrup if you're setting up a home soda routine.

If you're still choosing a carbonation machine, the Ninja Thirsti vs SodaStream breakdown and the Aarke vs SodaStream comparison both help you match a maker to the way you drink.

Sweeteners, calories and what's in the bottle

All four products in this comparison are sugar free, but the sweeteners differ. Jordan's lists zero sugar, zero calories and zero carbs on its coffee and simple syrups.

Torani's soda pack also lists zero sugar and zero carbs and is sweetened with sucralose.

Jordan's coffee syrups are gluten free, dairy free and kosher. The simple syrup is gluten free and keto friendly.

The signature pack is gluten free, keto and kosher. If you follow a specific diet, those labels are worth checking against your own rules before you buy.

Torani's pack uses sucralose plus acesulfame potassium in its ingredient list, along with fruit acids and preservatives. Some people notice a sucralose aftertaste in plain water, so try one flavor in a small glass before mixing a full pitcher.

The preservatives are there to keep opened bottles fresh, which matters more when you have four bottles to work through.

Neither brand's sugar free label means "tastes exactly like sugar." Both use sweeteners that carry their own character.

The practical move is to buy the smaller commitment first, taste it, and then size up once you know which flavors you actually finish. A sucralose-heavy syrup can taste fine in a fruity soda and less fine in a plain cup of coffee, so judge each flavor in the drink you'll actually make.

How to judge sweetness before you commit

Mix a single serving rather than a whole bottle. A tablespoon of Jordan's syrup in a mug of coffee is a fair way to test whether the sweetness level suits you.

For Torani, add a small splash to a glass of soda water and taste. Fruit flavors get stronger as you add more, but so does the sweetener.

Finding your ratio once saves you from pouring too much into every drink after. The pack's fruit acids also mean a little goes further in tea than in plain water, since the tea brings its own flavor to the mix.

Bottle sizes and how long a pack lasts

Every bottle in this comparison is 25.4 fl oz. The difference is how many bottles you get and whether they repeat a flavor or spread across several.

Jordan's vanilla comes as a two-pack of the same flavor. That's the right shape if vanilla is your daily driver and you don't want to run out mid-week.

The simple syrup is a single bottle. The signature pack is two bottles, but two different chocolate flavors.

Torani's soda pack is four bottles, each a different fruit. You get more variety in one order, but less depth in any single flavor.

If you fall in love with one of the four, you'll need to buy that flavor separately next time. The total across the pack is just over 100 fluid ounces, the largest volume in this comparison.

Matching pack size to your pour rate

Think about your week before you pick a pack shape. A household that makes two lattes a day will finish a vanilla two-pack faster than a household that makes one soda on weekends.

Match the pack to your pace, not to the biggest bottle count.

Torani's four-pack looks like the best value on paper, but only if all four flavors get used. If two bottles end up half full in the door, the extra volume was wasted.

Jordan's repeated-flavor packs are the opposite trade: less variety, but every bottle gets finished. A simple syrup single bottle is the smallest commitment of all, which suits someone testing whether sugar free sweetening works for them at all.

Who should buy which brand?

Buy Jordan's if coffee and dessert drinks fill your week; buy Torani if soda and iced tea do. The brand that matches your daily drink will get used, and the one that doesn't will sit in the cabinet.

Choose Jordan's Skinny Syrups if:

• You make coffee, lattes or iced coffee most days and want a flavor that fits all of them.
• You want a neutral sweetener for cocktails, tea or homemade soda without adding flavor.
• You like chocolate and espresso flavors and want a dessert-style syrup for evening drinks.
• You follow a keto, gluten free or kosher diet and want the labels to line up.

Choose Torani if:

• You carbonate water at home and want fruit flavors for Italian sodas.
• You drink iced tea and lemonade more than coffee.
• You'd rather try four flavors than commit to two bottles of one.
• You want a brand with a long soda and coffeehouse history behind its flavors.

If you're weighing syrup brands more broadly, our Monin gingerbread vs ginger syrup comparison shows how flavor choice changes within a single brand's lineup.

The verdict: Torani vs Jordan's Skinny Syrup

Jordan's Skinny Syrups wins this comparison for most readers. Its vanilla coffee syrup is the strongest all-round pick, and the simple syrup covers neutral sweetening needs that a flavored syrup can't.

Between the two brands, Jordan's gives you more ways to use one purchase across coffee, tea, shakes and cocktails.

Torani is the better buy in one clear case: you want fruity soda flavors and you carbonate at home. In that situation the four-bottle pack is more useful than any Jordan's pack here, and the fruit flavors do what they're built to do.

So the decision rule is simple. If your drinks are hot, or you want sweetness without flavor, buy Jordan's.

If your drinks are cold and bubbly, buy Torani. Most readers will get more use from the Jordan's vanilla pack, and it's the one we'd start with.

Frequently asked questions

Are Torani and Jordan's Skinny Syrups both sugar free?

Yes, both brands make sugar free lines, and every syrup in this comparison is sugar free. Jordan's Skinny Mixes lists zero sugar, zero calories and zero carbs on its coffee and simple syrups, and Torani's soda pack is sweetened with sucralose with zero sugar and zero carbs.

Which brand has more flavors, Torani or Jordan's Skinny Syrup?

Torani sells more than 100 syrups across its full range, while Jordan's Skinny Mixes focuses on sugar free coffee and drink flavorings. For this comparison, the four-product set here shows Jordan's strength in dessert and coffee flavors and Torani's strength in fruit flavors for soda.

Can I use Torani soda syrup in a SodaStream?

Yes, a sugar free syrup like Torani's fruit flavors can flavor carbonated water from a SodaStream. Add the syrup to the glass after carbonating the water, stir gently, and start with a small amount so the sweetness lands where you want it.

Which syrup pack is better for someone new to sugar free syrups?

Start with the Jordan's vanilla coffee syrup if you drink coffee or tea daily. If you mainly drink sparkling water and iced tea, the Torani soda variety pack gives you four fruit flavors to try before committing to a full bottle of one.

Do these syrups need to be refrigerated after opening?

Check the label on the bottle you buy and follow it. Both brands use preservatives in their syrups, and storage guidance can vary by flavor, so treat the bottle label as the authority rather than assuming all syrups keep the same way.