Best Soda Maker Syrup Brands
Torani is the soda maker syrup brand to start with, because its Soda Shop variety packs cover the fruit flavors home carbonators use most. Buy the original cane sugar pack for everyday Italian sodas and the sugar free pack when you want the same flavors with zero sugar.
On this page (8 sections)
- What makes a soda maker syrup brand worth buying?
- Why does Torani lead the soda maker syrup brands?
- Which Torani Soda Shop variety pack should you buy?
- How do the three Torani picks compare?
- How do you use soda maker syrup correctly?
- Which flavors work best in a home soda maker?
- How should you store and restock soda syrups?
- Final verdict: which soda maker syrup brands should you buy?
Torani is the soda maker syrup brand to start with. Its Soda Shop variety packs cover the flavors home carbonators use most, and the sugar free line gives you the same fruit profile with zero sugar.
No single brand wins every category, though, so the right pick depends on whether you want cane sugar, calorie-free sweetness or a classic root beer for floats.
Your machine makes the bubbles; the bottle you pour decides whether the glass tastes like a fountain soda or like fizzy water with a hint of fruit. This guide compares three Torani options, then explains how to choose between them and how to use them well.
What makes a soda maker syrup brand worth buying?
A good soda maker syrup brand gives you a concentrated flavor that holds up when diluted and mixes cleanly into carbonated water. Strength, sweetness and ingredient base matter more than the label art.
Torani has made flavored syrups since 1925, when Rinaldo and Ezilda Torre brought handwritten recipes from Lucca, Italy to San Francisco and used them to reintroduce the Italian soda. The company is still family-owned.
Three things separate a syrup built for soda from one built only for coffee:
- Dilution strength. A soda syrup is meant to be measured against water, so a little goes a long way. Coffee syrups can be thinner and sweeter by the ounce.
- Ingredient base. Torani's original line uses pure cane sugar, natural flavors and cold-filtered water. The sugar free line swaps in sucralose and acesulfame potassium.
- Flavor clarity. Fruit syrups should taste like the fruit, not like candy. Vanilla and root beer lean sweeter by design.
The brand matters because consistency matters. A bottle that varies from batch to batch makes it hard to repeat a drink you liked.
Torani describes a gold-standard process built around capturing the essence of each flavor, and the company has kept the same quality standards since its founders set them.
For a fuller look at fruit-forward bottles, see our roundup of the italian soda syrup options worth keeping on the shelf. That guide goes deeper on flavor variety than this one does.
Pick a brand whose base you like first, then choose flavors. If you want cane sugar, stay with original Torani.
If you count carbs, the sugar free line is the one to compare against.
Why does Torani lead the soda maker syrup brands?
Torani leads because it sells variety packs built around soda, not just coffee, and the flavors inside match what home carbonator owners often pour. The breadth of the range makes it easy to restock one flavor without buying a new set.
The Soda Shop packs put four 25.4 fl oz bottles in one box. That size is a practical middle ground: big enough to last several weeks of daily sodas, small enough that you can try a flavor without committing to a case.
Torani also sells single bottles in more than 100 flavors, so the variety pack is a starting point rather than a limit.
Three strengths stand out for soda makers:
- Soda-first flavor sets. The Soda Shop packs lead with Vanilla, Peach, Raspberry and Strawberry, which are the classic Italian soda flavors.
- Two sweetness systems. Original uses cane sugar; sugar free uses sucralose and acesulfame potassium and is keto friendly.
- One brand, many uses. The same bottle flavors iced tea, lemonade, milkshakes, mocktails and shaved ice.
The trade-off is that Torani is not the cheapest bottle per ounce, and its sugar free flavors carry a sweetener finish that some people notice. The Soda Shop set covers four flavors, so you will not find every fruit you might want in that one box.
You buy into the range, then expand.
If you are still deciding on the machine itself, our philips soda maker guide covers what that unit includes and who it suits. The syrup advice here applies to any carbonator.
Which Torani Soda Shop variety pack should you buy?
Buy the original cane sugar pack for the truest fountain soda taste, and the sugar free pack when calories or carbs are the deciding factor. Each covers Raspberry, Peach and Strawberry; the original adds Vanilla and the sugar free pack adds Coconut.
Here are the three bottles we would put in a first order, ranked by how well each serves a home soda maker.
1. Torani Soda Shop Syrup Variety Pack: best overall
Best for first-time soda maker owners. The Torani Soda Shop Syrup Variety Pack is the strongest starting point because it gives you four fruit flavors in one order and all of them work in carbonated water.
Its score of 8.9 reflects the flavor range, the bottle size and how directly the set is aimed at soda.

Four 25.4 fl oz bottles of Vanilla, Peach, Raspberry and Strawberry, the core flavors for Italian sodas at home.
See it on AmazonThe set includes one 25.4 fl oz bottle each of Vanilla, Peach, Raspberry and Strawberry. That covers 101.6 fluid ounces in total.
Vanilla is the versatile one: it softens a too-tart fruit soda and makes a decent cream soda base when you add a splash of half and half.
Peach and Strawberry suit a hot afternoon. Raspberry is the strongest and works best measured sparingly.
Torani makes the original line with pure cane sugar, natural flavors and cold-filtered water.
That base is why these syrups taste rounder than the cheapest soda syrups on the market.
The bottles are 750 ml each, so they fit standard pour spouts and pump tops. A pump makes measuring easier and keeps the pour consistent, which matters more for soda than for coffee.
Pick this pack if you are new to home carbonation and want to find your favorite flavor before buying full-size bottles. Skip it if you already know you only drink one flavor; a single bottle costs less than a four-pack you will not finish.
The set is also a natural match for the fruit-forward drinks in our how to make italian soda walkthrough.
2. Torani Sugar Free Soda Syrup Variety Pack: best for low-sugar drinks
Best for calorie counters and keto diets. The Torani Sugar Free Soda Syrup Variety Pack delivers fruit flavors with zero sugar and zero carbs.
Its score of 8.6 puts it just behind the original, mostly because sucralose changes the finish.

Four 25.4 fl oz bottles of Raspberry, Coconut, Strawberry and Peach, sweetened with sucralose instead of sugar.
See it on AmazonThe pack contains one 25.4 fl oz bottle each of Raspberry, Coconut, Strawberry and Peach. Coconut is the interesting one here; it makes a good cream soda or a tropical soda when paired with lime.
Raspberry, Strawberry and Peach cover the fruit basics.
Torani sweetens this line with sucralose (Splenda brand) and adds acesulfame potassium, so the sweetness lands differently than cane sugar. The brand describes it as keto friendly with zero sugar and zero carbs.
It is also naturally fat free. If you are watching sugar intake but still want a flavored soda every day, this is the pack to reach for.
The flavor base also includes citric and tartaric acid plus xanthan gum, which gives the syrup body without sugar. That matters for soda: a thin sugar free syrup can taste watery once carbonated.
Choose this pack if sugar is the reason you stopped drinking soda. Skip it if you dislike the sucralose aftertaste; in that case, use less original syrup rather than switching.
A smaller pour of the cane sugar version keeps the calories down without the sweetener finish.
3. Torani Classic Root Beer Syrup: best for floats and shakes
Best for root beer floats and dessert drinks. Torani Classic Root Beer Syrup is the one bottle to add when you want a nostalgic soda or a float.
Its 8.6 score matches the sugar free pack, and the pump in the box makes it easy to measure.

A 25.4 fl oz glass bottle of root beer syrup with a pump included, for floats, shakes and homemade root beer.
See it on AmazonThis syrup carries the warm flavors of vanilla, wintergreen, ginger and licorice. Torani makes it without high fructose corn syrup and sweetens with pure cane sugar.
A 750 ml glass bottle arrives with a BPA-free pump, so you get portion control from the first pour.
Root beer is the most demanding soda to make at home because the flavor has to stand up to carbonation and, in a float, to ice cream. Torani's version is built for exactly that.
It also works in shakes and mocktails, so one bottle covers several desserts.
Pick this bottle if root beer floats are the reason you bought a soda maker, or if you want a caffeine-free soda with real depth. Skip it if you only drink light fruit sodas; a root beer bottle will sit on the shelf.
The classic soda base also pairs well with tonic, and our guide to the sodastream tonic water syrup options covers that mixer category in more detail.
How do the three Torani picks compare?
The original Soda Shop pack wins on flavor and range, the sugar free pack wins on carbs and calories, and the root beer bottle wins on dessert drinks. Use this table to match each one to your own soda habit.
| Pick | Flavors | Sweetener | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soda Shop Variety Pack | Vanilla, Peach, Raspberry, Strawberry | Pure cane sugar | First-time soda maker owners |
| Sugar Free Soda Syrup Variety Pack | Raspberry, Coconut, Strawberry, Peach | Sucralose and acesulfame potassium | Low-sugar and keto drinks |
| Classic Root Beer Syrup | Root beer | Pure cane sugar | Floats, shakes and dessert sodas |
The two variety packs both hold 101.6 fluid ounces across four bottles. The root beer bottle is 25.4 fluid ounces on its own.
That means the packs are the better buy if you want to try several flavors, while the root beer is the better buy if you want one flavor in depth.
The original pack covers Vanilla, which the sugar free pack does not. The sugar free pack covers Coconut, which the original does not.
If you want both Vanilla and Coconut in your cupboard, you would need two packs or two single bottles.
Pick the original pack first if you are undecided. It teaches you how much syrup you like per glass without sweetener aftertaste, and you can move to sugar free once you know your favorite flavor.
Starting sugar free can make it harder to judge whether the drink or the sweetener is the issue.
How do you use soda maker syrup correctly?
Pour the syrup into the glass after you carbonate the water, not into the machine's bottle. Adding syrup before carbonation can foam over the machine and leave a sticky mess inside.
The order matters more than most people expect. Carbonate plain water first, then open the machine slowly, pour the syrup into a glass and top with the carbonated water.
Stir gently once; aggressive stirring knocks the bubbles out.
A workable starting ratio is about 1 ounce of syrup per 12 ounces of carbonated water. Adjust from there:
- Fruit flavors can take a little more syrup because the acid keeps the sweetness in check.
- Root beer and vanilla are stronger, so start lower and add.
- Sugar free syrup may need a touch more than the original version to match the sweetness you expect.
Chill the water before carbonating if your machine allows it. Cold water holds carbonation better, and the finished soda stays fizzy longer.
Use a glass with room for the foam; syrup can set off a brief fizz-up when it hits the water.
Store opened bottles in a cool, dark spot and check the label for how long the syrup keeps after opening. A pump top helps here too, since it limits how much air gets into the bottle.
If you use a lot of syrup, keep one pump per flavor rather than swapping a single pump between bottles.
Measure both the syrup and the water for the first few glasses. Once you know your ratio, you can pour by eye and still get a consistent drink.
Which flavors work best in a home soda maker?
The flavors that work best are the ones that stay distinct when diluted and carbonated: fruit, vanilla and root beer. Very delicate flavors fade in fizzy water, so save them for still drinks.
Raspberry is the strongest fruit flavor in both packs and the safest first pour. Strawberry and Peach are milder and suit a lighter soda.
Vanilla softens anything and makes a passable cream soda with a splash of cream. Coconut makes a tropical soda that pairs well with lime or pineapple.
Root beer is the outlier. It is not a fruit flavor and it is not subtle, but it is one of the few soda flavors that genuinely improves when you make it at home.
A float with vanilla ice cream is the classic use, and a shake with the same syrup is the next step.
Flavors to skip in a soda maker include anything described as a dessert syrup first. Caramel and chocolate syrups are built for coffee and milk, and they can taste thin in carbonated water.
Save those for lattes and use the soda-focused flavors for your machine.
Start with three flavors, not ten. A small set tells you which direction you like before you buy single bottles.
The Soda Shop pack is designed for exactly that first step.
How should you store and restock soda syrups?
Store syrups sealed, cool and out of direct sun, and restock the flavor you finish first. Glass bottles like the root beer keep flavor better than plastic once opened.
Heat and light break down flavor over time, so a cupboard away from the stove is better than the countertop. Keep the cap tight and wipe the threads after each pour; sticky syrup attracts dust and makes the cap hard to open.
Restocking is where variety packs help. Once you know which of the four bottles you use fastest, buy that flavor as a single bottle and keep a pack for the others.
That keeps your shelf stocked without buying flavors you never reach for.
If you make soda daily, plan on roughly one 25.4 fl oz bottle per flavor every few weeks. That estimate depends on your pour size and how often you drink it.
A pump top makes the bottle last longer because you stop guessing.
Keep a spare bottle of your favorite flavor so you are never out on a hot afternoon. Rotate the older bottle to the front of the cupboard when the new one arrives.
Final verdict: which soda maker syrup brands should you buy?
Buy the Torani Soda Shop Syrup Variety Pack first, because it gives you the core soda flavors in one order and the cane sugar base tastes right in carbonated water. That is the pick for most people, and it is the one we would buy again.
The other two picks are for specific needs. Choose the Sugar Free Soda Syrup Variety Pack if sugar or carbs are the reason you want a syrup at all.
Choose the Classic Root Beer Syrup if floats and shakes are your goal, or if you want one flavor in depth.
The wider soda maker syrup brands market includes cheaper bottles and smaller flavor ranges, but Torani covers the flavors home carbonators actually use with a base that holds up. Start with the original pack, find your flavor, then branch out.
For more fruit options, see our roundup of the best italian soda syrup picks. For the recipe side, our how to make italian soda guide shows the pour order.
And if you are still choosing a machine, our Philips Soda Maker review explains what that unit gives you. One more bottle to keep in mind is a good sodastream tonic water syrup for gin and tonics at home.
Our score weighs specs, features and buyer feedback against what you're shopping for. Use it as a starting point, then pick the sweetness system and flavor set that match how you actually drink soda.
Frequently asked questions
Do soda maker syrups work with any carbonated water machine?
Yes. Soda maker syrups are poured into a glass after you carbonate the water, so they work with any machine brand.
Carbonate plain water first, then stir the syrup in gently so the bubbles survive.
How much syrup do you use per glass of soda?
Start with about 1 ounce of syrup for a 12-ounce glass of carbonated water, then adjust to taste. Stronger flavors like root beer need less, while light fruit flavors can take a little more.
Is soda maker syrup the same as cocktail syrup?
Often yes. Torani syrups are made for coffee, sodas, teas and cocktails alike, so one bottle can cover several drinks.
Why does my homemade soda taste less sweet than a canned one?
Syrups are concentrated, so the ratio matters more than the pour. Too much water dilutes both flavor and sweetness, while too little syrup makes the drink sharp.
Measure both for a consistent glass.
About this guide: Our look at soda maker syrup brands for home carbonation draws on maker specs, materials and what owners report. See how we research.



