Ninja Soda Maker vs SodaStream: Which to Buy? (November 2026)
Buy SodaStream if you want a machine with screw-in CO2 cylinders you can refill cheaply and flavor with branded syrups. Pick a Ninja soda maker if you want to carbonate and flavor in one step. For most homes the wider SodaStream setup wins on running costs and flavors.
On this page (7 sections)
Buy SodaStream if you want a machine with screw-in CO2 cylinders you can refill cheaply and flavor with branded syrups. Pick a Ninja soda maker if you want to carbonate and flavor in one step.
For most homes the wider SodaStream setup wins on running costs and flavors.
The Ninja soda maker vs SodaStream question comes up because both brands promise sparkling drinks at home. They reach that goal by different roads: one is built around flavor pods, the other around gas and syrup you add yourself.
This comparison focuses on how each system works, what its CO2 costs you over time, and which household each one fits.
Ninja soda maker vs SodaStream: the quick verdict
Go SodaStream for the lower running cost and the broadest flavor choice. Go Ninja if the appeal of pressed-button flavor pods is worth paying more per drink.
SodaStream has the edge because its refill path is cheaper. A pack of two Simpli Soda 60L cylinders covers 120 liters of fizz, and you buy syrup in pour bottles or drops.
That 120 liters is the part that matters. Each cylinder holds 60 liters of beverage-grade CO2, so the pair in one pack covers a lot of steady daily drinking before you need to exchange them.
Ninja's strength is convenience: one machine, one click, flavored drink. Its flavor pods cost more per serving than a bottle of SodaStream syrup that you measure yourself.
If you mainly want plain sparkling water with a splash of fruit, SodaStream is the clear pick. If you want a cola-style drink with no measuring, Ninja has the simpler button.
One more detail on the SodaStream side: the flavors are sold as branded pour bottles. The zero-sugar pack covers four familiar soda tastes in a single order, so you are not hunting shelves for a single flavor you might not like.
Our Ninja Thirsti vs SodaStream comparison goes deeper on the two flagship machines. This post stays on the wider brand question.
How each brand carbonates water
Both push CO2 into chilled water; the difference is what happens next. SodaStream stops at the fizz and leaves flavor to you, while Ninja continues into a flavor step.
With SodaStream you fill the bottle, press to carbonate, then pour syrup or drops into the finished water. The maker never handles flavor, which keeps it simple to clean.
That separation has a practical side. The gas cylinder and the flavor bottle are two separate purchases, so you can run out of one without replacing the other.
You can also switch flavors mid-bottle if you only flavor the glass you are drinking.
Ninja machines are built to deliver flavor as part of the drink, using pods that the machine adds after carbonating. That saves a step but ties you to Ninja's pod lineup.
The fizz itself is similar: both use pressurized CO2 and a bottle that seals to the machine. Neither adds anything to the gas.
Chill your water before carbonating. Cold water holds bubbles better, and both systems give a livelier result with water from the fridge.
If your tap runs warm, fill the bottle and give it time in the fridge before you press the button.
Where the CO2 cylinder differences matter
SodaStream blue screw-in makers and Ninja machines can share the same cylinder type. That's where the Simpli Soda pack earns its keep.

Two 60L screw-in cylinders cover SodaStream blue screw-in makers and the Ninja Thirsti with 99.9% beverage-grade CO2.
See it on AmazonSodaStream's quick-connect models, such as Terra, Gaia and Art, use a different connector. Those need SodaStream's own quick-connect cylinders, not this pack.
The same goes for the pink quick-connect cylinders sold for some models.
Ninja's cylinder approach depends on the model, so match the cylinder to the machine you buy. The shared screw-in format is the reason a single refill source can cover both brands.
The cylinders themselves are aluminum, which keeps them light to handle during an exchange. The gas inside is 99.9% pure beverage grade, filled at the company's facility near Madison, Wisconsin.
For a home drink setup, that grade is the number to look for, since it is the same standard used for drinks meant for people rather than workshop tools.
If you're weighing the SodaStream range itself, our SodaStream MIX vs Terra guide explains the quick-connect split before you commit.
Running costs: which system is cheaper to own?
SodaStream costs less per liter of fizz. A 60-liter cylinder spreads across many bottles of sparkling water, and you flavor only what you drink.
The math is easy to follow. Two cylinders give you 120 liters of gas.
A household that drinks a liter of sparkling water a day gets months of fizz from one pack before an exchange. Ninja's pod cost starts on day one and repeats with every flavored drink.
Ninja's flavor pods carry a per-drink price on top of the gas. That convenience has a cost, and heavy drinkers feel it faster.
Syrup is the other half. A SodaStream pour bottle of Pepsi Wild Cherry Zero makes about 24 drinks, so you can plan cost per glass.
Four bottles in the variety pack work out to about 96 drinks.

Four zero-sugar pour bottles of Pepsi Wild Cherry, MTN Dew Code Red, Starry and Mug Root, about 96 drinks in all.
See it on AmazonThe pour bottle is worth a note. Each bottle holds 14.9 fl oz, and the spout cap lets you tip syrup to the flavor line, which is about half an inch above the water fill line or roughly 3 tablespoons.
That is a measured pour without a separate jigger.
If plain water is your goal, drops stretch furthest. One Bubly drops bottle makes about 36 cans of flavored sparkling water.

Six unsweetened Bubly drop bottles, zero calories and about 36 drinks per bottle, for sparkling water with a hint of fruit.
See it on AmazonSix bottles at 36 drinks each is over 200 glasses from one pack. The drops are unsweetened natural flavor essence with no calories and no sweeteners, so the only cost beyond the gas is the drops themselves.
For a fruity, lightly sweet drink, Bubly Burst sits in the middle.

Three Bubly Burst pour bottles in Cherry Lemonade, Peach Mango and Watermelon Lime, about 72 drinks with 45 calories per 12 oz.
See it on AmazonBubly Burst is the sweet spot between drops and full syrup. Each of the three bottles makes about 24 12-oz servings, or 9 liters, and each serving carries 45 calories.
Three flavors in rotation means you are not stuck with one taste for months.
The rule: the plainer your drink, the cheaper both systems run. Flavor is where the bills add up.
A household that mostly drinks plain fizz will see the gap between the two brands widen fastest.
What the exchange routine actually involves
The Simpli Soda model is a mail-in exchange. You send back empty cylinders and get refilled ones, which is how the pack keeps its cost down.
The company runs a lean operation and fills in-house, and it says that is what lets it pass savings to customers.
Plan for the turnaround. Keep both cylinders in the pack in rotation: one in the machine, one ready to ship.
That way the mail cycle never leaves you without gas. A single-cylinder setup is where people get caught out, because the machine sits idle while the empty is in transit.
This is the routine Ninja pod buyers skip. Pods arrive ready to use with no exchange step.
That is the trade: less hassle, more cost per drink.
Flavor choice: pods vs bottles and drops
SodaStream wins on variety. Between cola-style syrups, Bubly Burst pour bottles and drops, you can chase almost any taste.
Ninja's pods are convenient but narrower. You buy the flavors Ninja sells, and a pod is one drink's worth.
With SodaStream you control strength. Add half a pour, taste, then top up.
That's harder with a sealed pod.
The pour bottle design on the newer SodaStream flavors helps here. A spout lets you tip syrup to the flavor line without a funnel.
The line itself is a guide, not a rule, so you can stop short for a lighter drink.
Drops go further for subtle drinks. They add fruit essence with no sweetener, which suits people who find syrups too sweet.
The six-flavor Bubly pack covers strawberry, grapefruit, blackberry, lime, mango and cherry, so there is a taste for most moods.
The zero-sugar pack covers the other end: cola-style drinks with no sugar and no calories. Pepsi Wild Cherry, MTN Dew Code Red, Starry and Mug Root give you four soda flavors that people already know, which helps if the household includes skeptics.
Ninja's pod system cannot match that breadth in one order. You pick from what Ninja sells, and the flavor and the fizz come as a package.
The upside is speed. The downside is that a flavor you dislike is a pod wasted, while a syrup you dislike is a bottle you can still mix weaker.
Matching the flavor to the drink
Sort your household by what it actually drinks. Plain sparkling water fans want drops.
Diet soda fans want the zero-sugar pour bottles. People who want something fruity but not as sweet as soda land on Bubly Burst.
That sorting is the real reason SodaStream flavors matter to the Ninja comparison. Ninja's pods push every drinker toward one format.
SodaStream lets one machine serve three different tastes from the same cylinder.
Machine and bottle compatibility
Keep SodaStream bottles with SodaStream and Ninja bottles with Ninja. Each bottle is made for its own maker's pressure and fit.
SodaStream's lineup splits into screw-in and quick-connect makers. Bottles and cylinders follow that split.
A quick-connect machine needs its own cylinders and its own bottles.
Ninja's machines use their own bottles and pods. A SodaStream bottle won't seat in a Ninja machine, and the reverse is true.
Cylinders are the exception. The blue screw-in format crosses brands, which is why one refill pack can serve both.
The Simpli Soda pack fits SodaStream blue screw-in makers, plus Drinkmate, Aarke, Ninja and Philips. It does not fit the pink quick-connect models.
Check the machine's connector before you buy cylinders. Quick-connect SodaStream models need their own gas, and that's the most common buying mistake.
The cylinder you save money on is the one that fits your machine, not the one on sale.
The checklist before you buy
Read the connector type on the machine box. Blue screw-in means the Simpli Soda pack will work.
Quick-connect means you buy SodaStream's own cylinders.
Check the bottle count. A second bottle lets you keep one chilling while you drink the other, and it matters more with SodaStream because you fill and carbonate in the same bottle.
Check the flavor plan. If you want pods and nothing else, Ninja is the machine.
If you want to choose strength and flavor, SodaStream's bottle and drop format gives you that control.
Who should buy which?
Pick SodaStream for cheap fizz and flavor freedom. Pick Ninja for one-button flavored drinks.
Buy SodaStream if you drink a lot of sparkling water
You want plain bubbles most days, with flavor now and then. You're happy to pour syrup yourself.
You like the idea of a 60-liter cylinder and a cheap refill.
A two-cylinder pack means a spare is always on hand. The zero-sugar pour bottles cover the soda moods, and drops handle the light, unsweetened days.
One machine, one gas type, three flavor routes.
Buy Ninja if convenience is the whole point
You want a flavored drink without measuring. You'll pay more per serving for that.
You don't mind staying inside one brand's pod lineup.
If the household includes people who will not touch a measuring pour, the pod is the feature that gets them drinking more water. That is a real benefit, and it is the main reason to accept the higher cost.
Buy neither if you only drink soda now and then
A soda siphon may suit you better. Our soda siphon vs SodaStream comparison covers the small-batch option.
If you like the SodaStream idea but want a steel-bodied machine, the Aarke vs SodaStream face-off is worth a read before you spend. The same screw-in cylinders feed the Aarke machines too, so the gas decision carries over.
The verdict
Most readers should buy SodaStream. The Ninja soda maker vs SodaStream choice comes down to cost against convenience, and SodaStream wins on both refills and flavors.
The gas is shared: a screw-in pack like the Simpli Soda cylinders can feed a SodaStream blue screw-in maker or a Ninja Thirsti. That means the refill decision doesn't lock you in.
You can start with SodaStream and keep the same cylinders if you later move to a Ninja machine that takes blue screw-in gas.
Pick SodaStream if you want to flavor your own way and keep cost per liter low. Pick Ninja if a pod-based drink is worth the premium to you.
Whichever you choose, start with plain fizz and one flavor. You'll learn your real per-week use fast, and that number tells you which system pays off.
Our score weighs specs, features and buyer feedback against what you're shopping for.
Frequently asked questions
Can you use SodaStream cylinders in a Ninja soda maker?
Yes, if both use the blue screw-in style. The Simpli Soda cylinders fit SodaStream blue screw-in makers and the Ninja Thirsti.
They don't fit SodaStream quick-connect models such as Terra or Art.
Does SodaStream or Ninja make cheaper fizzy water?
SodaStream usually costs less per liter once you use a mail-in refill, because a 60-liter cylinder spreads over many bottles and you add flavor yourself. Ninja's flavor pods add a per-drink cost on top of the gas.
Which makes plain sparkling water without flavoring?
Both carbonate plain water. SodaStream is the simpler path, since you can add Bubly drops or nothing at all.
Ninja is built around flavor pods, so plain water is not the main point.
Can you mix SodaStream flavors in a Ninja machine?
You can add SodaStream syrups to water carbonated in a Ninja machine, but the flavors are tuned to SodaStream makers. Start with less syrup than the bottle suggests and taste before adding more.
Do the two brands share bottle sizes?
No. SodaStream bottles are made for SodaStream machines and Ninja bottles for Ninja, so keep each bottle with its own maker.
Use only the bottle that comes with or is sold for your machine.
About this guide: Our look at Ninja soda maker vs SodaStream draws on maker specs, materials and what owners report. See how we research.



